Lessons learned from I Can Only Imagine 2 which hit theaters Friday, February, 20

What seemed like a finite conclusion unexpectedly became a story detailing how faith isn’t proven when pain disappears; it’s declared in the middle of it.

I Can Only Imagine 2 picks up years after redemption and reconciliation between a father and son. That son, who once feared his father, now wrestles with fears for his own child, determined not to let fear write the story.

Instead, he allows Tim Timmons’s story of hope to shape his faith and guide the legacy he is building alongside his son. Timmons wrote MercyMe’s hit song, “Even If,” from his own life, and the film reveals the powerful story behind it.

All three men are confronted with the same truth: faith is not a single breakthrough moment, but a daily surrender; an ongoing decision to trust God with what matters most.

Bart Millard learns that redemption doesn’t end when the past is healed; it begins again at home, through intentional relationship—not only with his son, but with God. His son Sam realizes that sacrifice and responsibility are required to pursue a dream, and that God must remain at the center of it. And Tim Timmons stands as living proof that God can do the impossible, even when circumstances don’t change.

Now, all three are declaring, “It is well,” over their futures—confident that no matter what comes, they are never alone.

That’s the message Bart Millard and actor John Michael Finley, who portrays him, hope audiences carry with them.

“I think the biggest thing is that life is messy. Sadly, the one thing we all have in common is what hurt and pain is.” Millard shares.

Finley echoes that sentiment saying, “I think humans are always looking for connection and looking for hope.”

It’s a similar reflection from Milo Ventimiglia, who describes playing Tim Timmons as deeply personal, especially while walking through difficult seasons of his own. He explains how Tim’s faith shows strength and grace while moving through hardship.

The film also highlights a theme many try to avoid: gratitude through grief.

Grief is a hard season. Holding space for gratitude in the middle of it can feel nearly impossible. Yet Scripture reminds us in Ecclesiastes 3 that there is a time for everything—a time to mourn, a time to heal. We are allowed to feel deeply. We are simply called not to let those feelings lead us into sin (Ephesians 4:26).

When someone passes away, we grieve. But for those who believe Jesus died for their sins, there is also hope. As 2 Corinthians 5:7–8 reminds us:

“For we walk by faith, not by sight… to be absent from the body is to be present with the Lord.”

If grief comes from financial strain, mental health battles, or a relationship falling apart, Romans 8:28 offers assurance:

“And we know that all things work together for good to those who love God, to those who are the called according to His purpose.”

Faith does not deny the fire. It declares that God is present in it.

If you’re walking through a season that feels overwhelming, take ten minutes this week to open your Bible, pray honestly, and invite God into the middle of your struggle—because hope isn’t found after the storm, it’s found with Him in it.

Overcoming Hopelessness: A 10-Minute Bible Study